← All articles
ControlProject tracking

A red status is information, not a failure

A status report has to make a decision easier for the reader. Here is the template I ran with the PM team, and what a calm red looks like.

Ionut Ilasi3 min read

A status report has two readers: the people who need to decide something, and the project manager, who needs to be honest with himself. I design the report for both. If it does not make a decision easier, it is paperwork.

One template for the whole PMO

I ran the status-report template with the PM team, so that every project was reported in the same shape. When every project looks the same on the page, a reader can compare them in minutes, and the missing parts stand out. The template has five parts:

The same shape every period has a second benefit. Reports that look alike show a trend, not just a snapshot, and a new reader can pick the project up without a briefing.

Two parts deserve a note. An action without an owner is a wish, and an action without a date is a hope, so I insist on both and carry open actions from one report to the next. Slippage is always reported with its reason, because a date that moved without an explanation invites guessing. A reason on the client side, on our side or in a scope decision leads to a different next step.

Two lines that are not numbers

The template also asks for team happiness and customer happiness. They are the first things I fill in and the last I would delete. Budget and timeline are lagging signals: by the time they move, something has already gone wrong. A tired team or a quiet customer shows up earlier.

Red, without panic

On one project I knew we would exceed the budget. I reported the status as red, without panic, and I argued clearly that the cause was a scope change and not poor delivery.

The template helps here. Its scope section shows the baseline and the changes, so the explanation is already written down before anyone asks for it. A red status is the point where a report is most useful, because it tells people where their attention is needed.

Red is a fact with a reason and a next step.

How I check my own report

I read my report as if I were someone else. Is there a decision I am asking for, and by when? Does every action have a named owner? Does the forecast agree with the timeline? If a reader has to ask me what a red means, the report has not done its job.

A report is only worth the effort if it is short and on time. A long report that arrives late reaches people after the moment to act. I would rather send a plain one-page report on the agreed day than a polished one that arrives after the meeting. An honest status given on time is worth more than a perfect one given late, because people can decide on it.

Previous articleThe forecast is the number that matters Next articleA risk needs an owner and a trigger

Working on something complex?

If this is how you want your next programme to be run, let's talk.